HOW DO YOU SHARE JESUS CHRIST WITH SOMEONE WHO DOESN'T BELIEVE IN GOD?

Question of the Week: When the Person You Love Doesn't Believe

Scriptural Foundation: Mark 16:15 (KJV)

“And he said unto them, Go ye into all the world, and preach the gospel to every creature.”

This Week's Question

From Marcus Blake, Age 26 — Wathena, Kansas

Pastor James,

I have a question. I love my cousin Jake, and I want him to know Jesus Christ as his Savior. He, however, is an atheist. He doesn't believe in the Trinity or the Bible.

How can I possibly share the gospel with him? Everything that I've tried so far has fallen on deaf ears.

I'd definitely appreciate your insight.

Pastor James Responds: Marcus, Don't Give Up on Jake!

Marcus, first of all, thank you for writing. And thank you for caring enough about your cousin to ask this question.

Let me begin by telling you something that I hope will take a little pressure off your shoulders.

You are responsible for sharing the Gospel. You are not responsible for making someone believe it!

That's an important distinction, and one that many well-meaning Christians fail to understand.

Jesus commanded us in Mark 16:15 to go into all the world and preach the Gospel to every creature.

Notice what He did not say.

He didn't say everyone would believe.

He didn't say everyone would agree.

And He certainly didn't say we were supposed to argue people into accepting Him!

He told us to GO AND TELL!

Our responsibility is to proclaim the truth with love, conviction, patience, and compassion.

The person hearing that truth must then decide how to respond.

And ultimately, it is the Holy Spirit who convicts the heart.

So, Marcus, don't measure your faithfulness by whether Jake has accepted Christ yet.

Measure it by whether you are faithfully representing Christ in what you say and how you live.

Now, let's talk about how you can approach your cousin.

1. Stop Trying to Win the Argument. Start Trying to Reach the Person.

One of the greatest mistakes Christians make when witnessing to atheists is treating every conversation like a debate that must be won.

We present an argument.

They present a counterargument.

We quote a Scripture.

They question the Bible.

We explain the Trinity.

They challenge the existence of God.

And before long, what began as an opportunity to share the Gospel becomes a contest to determine who knows more.

Marcus, let me tell you something.

You can win an argument and still lose the opportunity to reach someone's heart.

Jake is not simply an atheist.

He's your cousin.

He's someone you love.

He's a human being with thoughts, experiences, questions, disappointments, and reasons for believing what he believes.

Have you ever stopped and asked him why he doesn't believe in God?

Not to challenge him.

Not to correct him.

But simply to listen.

Perhaps he has never encountered a convincing explanation of Christianity.

Perhaps he has witnessed hypocrisy among professing Christians.

Perhaps he has struggled with suffering, injustice, or unanswered questions.

Or perhaps he has carefully considered the evidence and reached a different conclusion.

You won't know until you ask.

And when he answers, listen to understand, not merely to prepare your next response.

First Peter 3:15 instructs us to be ready to give an answer for our hope, but to do so with meekness and fear—that is, with gentleness and respect.

That's a good place to begin.

2. Start With What You Both Can See and Understand

Marcus, let me share something from my personal experiences witnessing to people who do not believe in God.

I have often found it helpful to begin with something we both recognize and can discuss without immediately opening a Bible.

For example, the natural world.

The sun.

The moon.

The stars.

The extraordinary complexity of life.

Sometimes I might ask a person:

“Have you ever looked up at the stars on a clear night and wondered how everything came to be?”

Or:

“When you consider how enormous our universe is, what do you believe explains its existence?”

Notice that I'm not immediately telling the person what to believe.

I'm asking a question.

I'm opening a conversation.

And I'm allowing the person to express what they think.

Now, here's something important.

An atheist may have scientific explanations for the development of stars, planets, and life. We should not dismiss those explanations simply because we disagree about whether God exists.

Science can describe many natural processes. Questions about why anything exists at all, whether creation has an ultimate purpose, and whether God exists are broader philosophical and theological questions.

As a Christian, I believe the heavens declare the glory of God, as Psalm 19:1 teaches.

But I also recognize that Jake may look at those same heavens and reach a different conclusion.

The purpose of the conversation is not to pretend that nature proves every Christian doctrine. It is to invite thoughtful consideration of life's deeper questions.

And that can become a starting point for discussing faith.

3. Consider the Miracle of Human Life

Another subject I have used in conversations with unbelievers is the human body.

Think about it.

Every one of us began as a tiny developing human life.

Through an extraordinary process of growth and development, a baby forms within its mother's womb.

The heart begins beating.

Organs develop.

The brain grows.

And eventually, a child is born who will learn to walk, talk, think, reason, love, and make decisions.

Now, I understand that biology explains much about how these processes occur.

But as a Christian, I see something more.

I see the remarkable intricacy of life as a reason to worship the Creator.

Psalm 139:14 declares:

“I will praise thee; for I am fearfully and wonderfully made...”

Marcus, you don't necessarily have to begin by quoting that verse to Jake.

You might simply ask:

“Jake, when you think about how human life develops, does it ever make you wonder whether there is a greater purpose behind our existence?”

Then let him answer.

He may agree.

He may disagree.

He may offer an entirely different explanation.

That's all right.

A genuine conversation is not a failure simply because the other person doesn't agree with you.

Remember, your goal is not to force Jake to acknowledge something he doesn't believe.

Your goal is to create an opportunity for honest dialogue that may eventually lead to a conversation about Jesus Christ.

4. Before You Explain Christianity, Make Sure You're Living It!

Now, Marcus, we're getting to something I consider absolutely essential.

And this applies not only to you, but to every Christian reading this message.

PRACTICE WHAT YOU PREACH!

I've been walking with the Lord for more than fifty years, and one of the most important lessons I've learned is that people pay attention to how Christians live.

They notice how we treat our families.

How we speak to others.

How we handle disappointment.

How we respond when someone disagrees with us.

Whether we're honest.

Whether we keep our promises.

And whether the love we talk about on Sunday is visible in our lives on Monday.

Let me put it another way.

If Jake sees you talking about the love of Jesus but treating people with contempt, what message do you think he receives?

If you tell him that Christ changes lives, but your own life consistently contradicts that message, why should he take your words seriously?

Now, none of us is perfect.

I certainly am not.

But there is a difference between a Christian who occasionally fails and humbly acknowledges it, and someone who claims to follow Christ while refusing to live according to His teachings.

Jesus said in Matthew 5:16:

“Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.”

Notice that Jesus connected our witness with our conduct.

Marcus, sometimes the most powerful thing you can do for Jake is demonstrate the character of Christ when nobody is expecting a sermon.

Be honest.

Be dependable.

Be compassionate.

Be patient.

And when you make a mistake, admit it.

Your life should never contradict the Gospel you're asking someone else to believe.

5. You Don't Have to Begin With the Bible, but You Must Eventually Share Jesus

Here's where I want to be especially careful, Marcus.

There is nothing wrong with beginning a conversation about God through nature, human life, personal experiences, or thoughtful questions.

But we must never confuse those conversations with the Gospel itself.

The Gospel is not merely the belief that a Creator exists.

It is the good news of what God has done for humanity through His Son, Jesus Christ.

And at some point, if Jake is willing to listen, you need to explain that message clearly.

You don't have to begin with complicated theological language.

You don't have to deliver a forty-five-minute sermon.

And you don't have to explain every doctrine of Christianity in one conversation.

You can begin with five simple truths.

The Gospel in Five Simple Truths

  1. God created us and loves us. We were made to know Him and live according to His purposes. (Genesis 1:27; John 3:16)

  2. We have all sinned. Every one of us has fallen short of God's perfect standard. (Romans 3:23)

  3. Sin separates us from God. We cannot make ourselves righteous through good works or religious activity. (Romans 6:23; Ephesians 2:8–9)

  4. Jesus Christ died for our sins and rose again. Through His death and resurrection, God offers forgiveness and reconciliation. (1 Corinthians 15:3–4)

  5. God calls us to repent and believe in Jesus Christ. Salvation is received by grace through faith, not earned by our efforts. (Mark 1:15; Romans 10:9–10)

That's the Gospel, Marcus.

Simple enough for a child to begin understanding, yet profound enough to occupy the greatest theological minds for a lifetime.

And let me add something.

Jake doesn't have to understand every aspect of the Trinity before he can begin considering who Jesus Christ is.

Certainly, the Trinity is an essential doctrine of historic Christianity. We must never deny or diminish it.

But rather than beginning with the most difficult theological questions, you might begin with a more personal one:

“Jake, what do you think about Jesus Himself?”

That question can open an entirely different conversation.

6. Don't Be Afraid of Questions You Cannot Answer

Marcus, sooner or later, Jake may ask you something you cannot answer.

Perhaps he'll ask:

“If God is loving, why does He allow children to suffer?”

Or:

“Why are there so many religions?”

Or:

“What evidence is there that Jesus actually rose from the dead?”

These are serious questions.

And they deserve serious answers.

But here's something I want you to remember.

You don't have to know everything to faithfully share what you do know.

There is nothing wrong with saying:

“Jake, that's a good question. I don't have a complete answer right now, but I'd be glad to study it and discuss it with you.”

That's not weakness.

That's honesty.

And honesty builds trust.

Don't manufacture explanations.

Don't misuse scientific discoveries.

Don't quote Scriptures out of context.

And don't pretend that every difficult question has an easy answer.

God does not need us to misrepresent the truth in order to defend Him.

Second Timothy 2:24–25 reminds us that the servant of the Lord must not strive, but should be gentle, patient, and able to teach.

Our attitude matters just as much as our willingness to speak.

7. Respect His Freedom to Say No

Now, Marcus, this may be the most difficult part of my response.

Jake has the freedom to reject what you believe.

You may not like that.

You may be deeply concerned about his spiritual condition.

You may wish with all your heart that he would accept Jesus Christ today.

But you cannot make that decision for him.

And you must not allow his unbelief to destroy your relationship with him.

If he asks you not to discuss religion, respect that boundary.

Continue loving him.

Continue being his cousin.

Continue showing him kindness.

And if he eventually chooses to reopen the conversation, be ready to listen and respond.

Sometimes Christians become so determined to deliver a message that they forget the person standing in front of them.

Jake is not a project to be completed. He is a person to be loved.

And your love for him should not depend upon whether he becomes a Christian.

Remember, Romans 5:8 tells us that Christ died for us while we were yet sinners.

God's love was demonstrated before we responded to Him.

Surely, we can demonstrate that same spirit toward those who do not share our beliefs.

8. Pray for Jake, but Don't Stop Being Jake's Cousin

Marcus, prayer is not a substitute for showing love, but it should certainly accompany our witness.

Pray for Jake.

Pray that God will give you wisdom.

Pray that your conversations will be respectful and meaningful.

Pray that Jake will be willing to consider the claims of Jesus Christ.

And pray that your own life will reflect the message you are sharing.

But don't make every family gathering an evangelistic campaign.

Go fishing together.

Share a meal.

Talk about work, family, sports, and everyday life.

Be there when he needs help.

Celebrate his accomplishments.

Comfort him during difficult times.

And allow your relationship to remain genuine.

There may come a day when Jake approaches you with questions you never expected.

There may not.

We cannot predict or guarantee another person's response.

But regardless of what happens, you can remain faithful to Christ and loving toward your cousin.

And that is no small thing.

9. Christian, Know What You Believe—and Why You Believe It!

Before I close, I want to address every Christian reading this week's question.

You cannot effectively communicate a faith that you have never taken the time to understand.

I believe the Bible is the inspired Word of God, from Genesis to Revelation.

That conviction is foundational to my life and ministry.

But merely owning a Bible doesn't mean you know what it teaches.

And occasionally quoting a familiar verse doesn't mean you're living according to its principles.

We must study the Scriptures.

We must understand the Gospel.

We must know what Jesus taught.

And we must allow the Word of God to shape our decisions, relationships, priorities, and conduct.

Second Timothy 2:15 instructs us:

“Study to shew thyself approved unto God, a workman that needeth not to be ashamed, rightly dividing the word of truth.”

Notice those words: rightly dividing the word of truth.

We must handle God's Word responsibly.

Not twisting it to win an argument.

Not using it to intimidate others.

Not selecting convenient passages while ignoring those that challenge our own conduct.

But studying it carefully and applying it faithfully.

Before you attempt to convince someone else that Christianity changes lives, make sure you're allowing Jesus Christ to change yours!

That is where effective Christian witnessing begins.

My Final Answer to Marcus

Marcus, let me bring everything together as simply as I can.

You love Jake.

You want him to know Jesus Christ.

You've tried talking to him, but nothing seems to be working.

So what should you do now?

Love him. Listen to him. Respect him. Pray for him. Live faithfully before him. And when he's willing to listen, share the Gospel clearly and without apology.

You can begin with the wonders of creation.

You can discuss the remarkable development of human life.

You can ask questions about purpose, morality, suffering, and the meaning of existence.

You can share your own testimony about what Christ has done in your life.

But remember that none of those conversations, by themselves, replaces the message of Jesus Christ crucified and risen.

Eventually, the discussion must come back to Him.

And when it does, don't be ashamed of the Gospel.

Romans 1:16 declares:

“For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth...”

Marcus, you don't have to be the world's greatest theologian.

You don't have to win every debate.

And you don't have to possess an answer to every question.

Just be a faithful witness and a loving cousin.

The rest is not yours to control.

And let me leave you with one final thought.

Don't become so focused on Jake's unbelief that you forget to demonstrate your own faith.

Because while Jake may not believe what you believe, he can still see how you live.

Make sure what he sees is consistent with the Jesus Christ you proclaim.

A Word to Our Readers

Perhaps you're reading this today, and you have a Jake in your family.

A son.

A daughter.

A husband.

A wife.

A brother.

A sister.

A friend.

Someone you love who does not believe in God.

Or perhaps you're the one who doesn't believe.

If so, I want you to know that you're welcome to read our ministry messages, ask questions, and examine the Christian faith without being ridiculed or pressured.

You don't have to pretend to believe something you don't.

And you don't have to agree with me to be treated with dignity and respect.

I simply invite you to consider the person and claims of Jesus Christ with an open and thoughtful mind.

For those of us who are Christians, remember this:

We are called to be witnesses, not prosecutors; ambassadors, not adversaries; servants, not spiritual salespeople.

We cannot compel faith.

But we can faithfully proclaim the truth.

And we can demonstrate the love of Christ in the process.

THE GOSPEL MUST BE HEARD—BUT IT SHOULD ALSO BE SEEN IN THE LIVES OF THOSE WHO PROCLAIM IT!

A Prayer for Marcus, Jake, and Our Unsaved Loved Ones

Heavenly Father,

Today, we lift Marcus and his cousin Jake before You.

You know their hearts, their experiences, their questions, and their circumstances.

Give Marcus wisdom, patience, humility, and compassion as he seeks to share his faith.

Help him to listen carefully, speak truthfully, and demonstrate genuine love.

And Father, we pray for Jake.

May he be willing to examine the claims of Jesus Christ honestly and thoughtfully. May his questions be met with patience, his concerns with respect, and his life with kindness.

We also pray for every family represented by those reading this message.

Some have been praying for loved ones for many years.

Some are discouraged.

Some are frustrated.

And some are afraid that their loved ones will never come to know Christ.

Strengthen their faith.

Remind them that their responsibility is to be faithful, loving witnesses.

And above all, help us to live lives that reflect the character of our Lord and Savior.

May everything we say and do bring glory to Jesus Christ.

In His precious name we pray.

Amen and Amen!

Have a Question for Pastor James?

Our Question of the Week is an opportunity to address real-life questions about Christianity, the Bible, family, faith, ministry, and the challenges we face in today's world.

No sincere question is too simple, and difficult questions are welcome.

If you have a question you'd like us to consider for a future article, contact us through our email: pom_ministry@yahoo.com or admin@renacakes.com

Our mission is to proclaim Jesus Christ, strengthen believers, encourage families, and reach precious souls with the Gospel.

If you would like to support our missionary outreach here in the Philippines, you may also contribute through our website, pomitaly.homestead.com.

Every prayer, every act of encouragement, and every contribution is appreciated.

Pastor James Langston
Senior Pastor | Missionary | Author
Pilgrim Outreach Ministries International
Philippines Mission — November 2026

Your Feet to the Nations.

Help us help them—one soul at a time.

🌐 Ministry: https://pomitaly.homestead.com

📚 Bookstore: https://thewilltosucceed.homestead.com

✍️ Ministry Blog: https://joybells49.blogspot.com

Suggested Hashtags and Mentions

#QuestionOfTheWeek #Mark1615 #ShareTheGospel #ChristianEvangelism #JesusChrist #FaithAndReason #ChristianWitness #PracticeWhatYouPreach #SalvationInChrist #PilgrimOutreachMinistries

@joybells49 @YouVersion @BibleGateway

Comments